What is Impact Investing?
Impact Investing Spectrum
Why Impact Investing?
Impact Investing Sectors
Who is Involved?
1. Impact Investing Fundamentals
Every day, the world faces hunger, inadequate healthcare, unsafe water, inequality, and challenges associated with climate change and a lack of natural resources.
Who’s going to solve these challenges?
Impact investing serves as a new investment strategy within many different companies, organizations, and funds -- nonprofit and for-profit -- with the intention to generate positive social and/or environmental impact.
2. The Impact Investing Spectrum
Impact investments generate social and/or environmental impact, as well as some expectation of a return of- and/or on invested capital.
Impact investors vary in their financial return expectations. While some seek competitive or market-rate returns, others may be willing to accept below market-rate returns to maximize impact.
The Impact Investment (Financial Return) Spectrum:
- Philanthropy: Grants that have an anticipation of generating social and/or environmental impact with no expectation of any return on capital
- Program-Related Investing (PRI): Investments made for the primary objective of achieving a social and/or environmental impact, with an expectation of a partial or full return of capital, and/or a limited return on the investment
- Impact First Investing: Investments that are willing to accept a lesser financial outcome -- either taking greater risks or accepting lower returns-- in order to achieve social and/or environmental impact
- Market-Rate Impact Investing: Investments that seek a full market-rate return, AND some measurable beneficial social and/or environmental impact
- Mainstream Investing: Investing with an expectation of a full market-rate return, but no beneficial impact
The universe of impact investing comes under the heading of many new terms: “socially responsible investing,” “sustainable investing”, “thematic investing”, “impact first”, and “double or triple bottom lines”, among others.
This spectrum of impact investing approaches can help differentiate between some of these types of investing based on their social/environmental impact:
- Philanthropy: Fully oriented to positive social and/or environmental impact
- Thematic Investing: Investments in thematic sectors that provide an explicit social and/or environmental benefit
- Sustainable Investing (ESG): Uses a positive investment screen to include environmental, social, and governance (ESG) consideration of companies that aims to generate a positive social and/or environmental impact, rather than just negative impact avoidance
- Socially Responsible Investing (SRI): While SRI integrates social and environmental factors in investment analysis, negative screening is a relatively passive strategy that ensures no negative impacts on society and/or the environment, but does not necessarily add to any positive outcomes
- Mainstream Investing: Investing in companies that have no consideration of beneficial social or environmental impact
3. Impact Sectors
Impact investing is based around two impact sectors: social and environmental.
- The social impact sector can range anywhere from healthcare, microfinance, food security, power, and housing.
- The environmental impact sector is based on the challenges that come with climate change, including: resource scarcity and conservation, energy efficiency, clean water, sustainable agriculture, food, and timber.
4. Why Impact Investing?
To solve global challenges:
Increasing millennial interest in social/environmental values
Major transfers of generational wealth
Institutions, individuals, foundations, pension funds, endowments, etc. aligning their investment capital with the ideals that they stand for.
Capital invested in impact investments:
Increasing consumer demand for environmental and/or socially oriented products and services
*** ESG: environmental, social, and governance consideration of companies
5. Impact Investing Sectors
While private equity offers the greatest opportunity for beneficial social and/or environmental impacts, impact investment opportunities exist across all asset classes.
- Shareholder Activism
- Credit, including project financing for social and/or environmental developments
- Hedge Strategies
- Renewable energy
- Sustainable agriculture and timber
- Green real estate
- Social Entrepreneurship
- Seed Capital
- Venture Capital
- Includes investing in: healthcare, green technology, sustainable agriculture, housing, clean water and conservation, inclusionary financing, etc.
6. Impact Performance
Impact investments can produce market-rate returns alongside long-term positive impact.
Reports show that portfolio performance meets or exceeds investor expectations for both social and/or environmental impact and financial return.
Impact and Financial Performance Relative to Expectations
How an investment performs financially varies based on the investor’s capabilities and objectives.
The Impact Investing Benchmark, an analysis of the financial performance of 51 impact-focused private equity and venture capital funds launched between 1998 and 2010, demonstrates that impact investments are capable of producing internal rates of return (IRR) equal to, and at times better than, traditional investments of comparable size and geography. The Report was produced by the Global Impact Investing Network and Cambridge Associates. As the first comprehensive analysis of the financial performance of impact investing funds, the Impact Investing Benchmark represents the first of many steps in understanding industry performance of impact investing. The Benchmark is part of the growing evidence for impact investments as a competitive financial product, working against the misconception that impact investments must sacrifice financial return in order to achieve social return.
Measuring the social and/or environmental impact also varies based on the objectives and strategies of the investment.
Different indicators determine environmental and social impact and help to demonstrate a net benefit to society.
Three of the top questions to consider when evaluating a company are:
1. How do companies value employees?
2. How is sustainability integrated into decision-making?
3. How efficiently are companies using natural resources?
Companies that demonstrate an integration of sustainability principles and practices into operating metrics are considered to be high impact to both individual and institutional investors. Knowable, public indicators provide information that allows both impact investors and conscious consumers to know that sustainability is part of the whole company, not just a sum of its parts.
Still, given the limited sample of investments, varied ways of measuring, and the overall newness of the market, additional research and an industry-wide accepted measurement will be necessary to draw conclusive results.
7. Challenges of Impact Investing
- Consistent Metrics
- Limited Demonstrated Results
- Limited Investment Options
- Startup Risk
- Institutional Reluctance
8. Who is Involved in Impact Investing?
- Financial Institutions
- Pension funds, banks, insurance companies
- Corporate and public, domestic and international (developed and emerging)
- Private Foundations
- Sovereign Wealth Funds
- Government Pension Fund Global, China Investment Corporation, etc.
- Development Finance Institutions (DFIs)
- International Finance Corporation
- Public Agencies
- U.S. Agency for International Development, International Trade Association, etc.
- Individual Investors
9. Examples of Impact Investing
Gender Lens Investing
Gender lens investing is investing that considers the benefits to women and girls, ranging from promoting gender equality and women’s empowerment in the U.S., to providing clean-burning stoves to women in Africa.
Gender lens investing will continue to be one of the most important types of impact investing. Companies with more women board directors outperform their male counterparts, and women tend to invest in areas that improve human wellbeing, such as maternal mortality, clean water, safe cook stoves, and children’s education- bringing accelerated social impact.
Food and Animal Investing
Some of the biggest investment institutions such as Bank of America, Morgan Stanley, and Merrill Lynch have joined with NGOS and leading food companies to discuss how their portfolios could impact the food industry.
Only several years ago, animal welfare in companies was rarely considered to investors, and if the issue did come up was likely only featured occasionally on negative screening lists for specific ethics-based investors.
Recently, farm standards have been seen as a rising business risk to companies looking to invest, not only for the welfare of the animals, but for the environment, human health pandemics such as the swine flu, and the withering company value.
The term cruelty-free investing is investing in companies that do not support animal exploitation or cause any harm to animals. Cruelty-free investing options have become and will continue to be increasingly more available in the next few years as consumers and companies become more concerned with both the environmental and ethical issues surrounding animal exploitation.
Supported by the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation