Criticism of Chan Zuckerberg Initiative and Implications for Impact Investing Industry - The Challenges in Using Market Forces to Do Good

By: Andrew Luu | December 19, 2015

Facebook co-founder and CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, announced earlier this week that he and his partner, Dr. Priscilla Chan, would devote 99% of their wealth, approximately $45 billion, to create social good by making impact investments in sectors such as health, education, scientific research, and energy. The announcement came in the form of an open letter announcing the pair’s launch into parenthood, through the birth of their daughter, and the impact investing industry, through the founding of the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative (CZI), LLC.

Zuckerberg and Chan’s announcement was met with mixed reception. While some celebrated the pair’s efforts, others criticized CZI for its LLC structure, calling into question the motives involved, particularly the tax implications of the LLC structure as well as CZI’s abilities as an LLC to invest in for-profit companies, potentially make political contributions, and avoid disclosure obligations.

Zuckerberg responded to criticisms via Facebook to dispel initial concerns. Primarily, Zuckerberg stated that he and Chan receive no tax benefit from transferring their shares to CZI and that the LLC model was favored over a nonprofit foundation structure to provide flexibility and agility in financing impact projects.

While Zuckerberg is not the first tech entrepreneur to contribute their fortune to the benefit of society through an LLC – for instance, eBay Founder Pierre Omidyar created his own impact investing firm, the Omidyar Network, structured as both an LLC and nonprofit foundation, providing flexible financing in the form of investments and grants –  the initial criticisms of CZI are instructive to general concerns surrounding the impact investing, which may persist as the amount of capital and the number of potential players in the industry continue to grow.

In an interview with NPR, Stacy Palmer, editor of the Chronicle of Philanthropy, discusses impact investing and the perceived dichotomy between nonprofits and market forces. Stacy notes, “there is an important change happening. And one of the things that’s been part of this conversation is how can we use the market to better advantage… there are people who think this is a great idea and [those] who are concerned about it because they said the whole reason philanthropy and nonprofits exist is to correct what the market does wrong”. However, as regulation around the impact investing industry, particularly related to fiduciary responsibility and risk assessment of impact investments, continues to change, the line between market forces and nonprofit efforts begins to blur (See: IRS Ruling Makes Impact Investments More Accessible for Private Foundations).  
As impact investing continues to evolve as an industry, impact investors may inevitably have to mitigate public concern and general skepticism surrounding the use of market forces to alleviate social ills. While the number of realized impact investments continue to grow – adding to the body of evidence surrounding financial and impact performance of the industry – the strategies used by impact investors may also greatly influence perception of the impact investing as a whole. 

Comments

Robin jack

Thanks for every other informative site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information. <a href="http://voyance-amour-eternel.com">voyance par téléphone non surtaxé</a>

jack men

Your content is nothing short of brilliant in many ways. I think this is engaging and eye-opening material. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers. <a href="http://thefootandlegclinic.co.uk/plantar-fasciopathy/">plantarfasciitis Glasgow</a>

jack men

This is very informatics, fresh and clear. I feel that everything has been portrayed in methodical way with the goal that peruser could get greatest data and realize numerous things. <a href="https://www.europages.de/WHEELSSHOP/00000005330525-627727001.html">https://www.europages.de/WHEELSSHOP/00000005330525-627727001.html</a>

jack men

Great outlined data. I thank you about that. Doubtlessly it will be extremely helpful for my future tasks. Might want to see some different posts on the same subject! <a href="https://www.disusa.de/wheelsshop-66754.htm">https://www.disusa.de/wheelsshop-66754.htm</a>

jack men

Cool stuff you have got and you keep update all of us. <a href="https://apofraxeis-247.gr/">apofraxeis</a>

Robin jack

Fascinating and stunning how your post is! It Is Useful and accommodating for me That I like it all that much, and I am anticipating Hearing from your next.. <a href="http://www.apofraktiki-attikis.gr/apofraxeis-kifisia.html">apofraxeis kifisia</a>

Robin jack

Thanks for discussing your ideas in this article. The other matter is that if a problem occurs with a computer system motherboard, people should not consider the risk of repairing this themselves because if it is not done properly it can lead to permanent damage to the complete laptop. It will always be safe to approach any dealer of your laptop for any repair of its motherboard. They have technicians who’ve an experience in dealing with mobile computer motherboard issues and can make right analysis and perform repairs. <a href="http://voyance-amour-eternel.com">voyance amour gratuite</a>

jack men

Much obliged for a superb offer. Your article has demonstrated your diligent work and experience you must this field. Splendid .i cherish it perusing. <a href="https://www.bestromanianescorts.com/">Luxury Romanian Escorts</a>

jack men

Great artcile, yet it would be better if in future you can share more about this subject. Continue posting. <a href="http://voyance-amour-eternel.com">voyance amour gratuite</a>

jack men

This is highly informatics, crisp and clear. I think that everything has been described in systematic manner so that reader could get maximum information and learn many things. <a href="http://www.zoomblilivehelp.com/">http://www.zoomblilivehelp.com/</a>

Pages

Andrew Luu

Popular Impact Articles

Subscribe to the blog

By email

By RSS